top of page

Review: Much Ado About Nothing

Writer: The Verdict
The Verdict
10 hours ago
5 min read
The cast of Much Ado About Nothing
The cast of Much Ado About Nothing

🌟VERDICT’S PICK🌟


It seems absolutely insane to suggest that a revival of Much Ado About Nothing, starring two of the most recognizable faces from the Marvel universe, could offer the closest thing to an authentic audience experience at the Globe in 1600. And yet, who would think that a play written over 400 years ago, now featuring cell phones and more pink confetti than I have ever seen before, could transport a Broadway audience all the way back to Elizabethan London? Having made that absurd claim, I guess I need to prove why Jamie Lloyd’s revival of this Shakespearean tale of love, deception, and a “merry war” of wits manages to do just that.


Of course, it’s not exactly a one-to-one comparison: padded theatre seats replace backless wooden benches, modern stage lighting allows performances to begin at 8 p.m. without relying on daylight (or risking a fire), and you’re not standing in a downpour of rain—just the aforementioned pink confetti. The similarity, however, lies in the connection between performers and audience. Tom Hiddleston and Hayley Atwell, playing Benedick and Beatrice, know they have plenty of adoring fans in the house and don’t shy away from small moments of interaction, whether pointing out individual theatregoers or giving a knowing nod to someone laughing in the front row.


Much Ado About Nothing
Much Ado About Nothing

Director Jamie Lloyd has polarized audiences in recent years with his ambitious, unconventional revivals on both sides of the Atlantic, including the Tony-winning Sunset Blvd. from two years ago and the upcoming revival of Evita. Known for stripping productions back to uplift the material, Lloyd takes a similar approach with Much Ado. But just as Sunset Blvd. had its enormous cantilevering screen and Evita its much-talked-about balcony scene, this production has its own “gimmick”: confetti. Falling continuously throughout the show, from a slow trickle during weighty moments to a monsoon during musical numbers, it tracks the emotional pace of the play, highlighting the effusive joy at its heart.


What this production does exceptionally well, however, is handle the tonal shift in the second half. It would be so easy to keep riding the high, but Lloyd creates a transition that feels like a continuation of the show rather than an entirely new play—a distinction that could easily be lost. Don John’s scheme to destroy the planned marriage between Hero (Mara Huf) and Claudio (James Phoon) sends shockwaves through the company, particularly affecting Beatrice and Benedick, whose relationship takes on a newfound seriousness amid the chaos. The shift is reflected in the sudden halt of the falling confetti before the show lightens up again, ending this comedy with a traditional Shakespearean wedding—set, of course, to David Guetta’s “When Love Takes Over.”


Tom Hiddleston & Hayley Atwell
Tom Hiddleston & Hayley Atwell

Tom Hiddleston and Hayley Atwell lead this production as Benedick and Beatrice. Their star power is sensational: Hiddleston gives one of the most brilliant performances I’ve seen in a while, capturing everything that makes Benedick so lovable. His captivating charm makes it impossible to look away, and he finds every nook and cranny of the character, from the goofy moments—hiding under a pile of confetti and comically spitting out the pieces that inevitably land in his mouth—to his more somber moments once confronted by Beatrice’s ire. Their charged dynamic is immediately evident in their squabbling, though each remains convinced the other can't stand them.


It would be easy to get swept away by Hiddleston’s effervescent charm, but Atwell more than holds her own. Her Beatrice has the fiery, biting wit to perfectly complement Benedick’s silliness, resulting in some fantastic exchanges and a wonderfully joyous chemistry. The cardboard cutouts of their Marvel alter egos provide some fun moments, along with plenty of knowing winks to fans in the house. Typically, I absolutely despise these moments, but somehow, even I was won over by these two brilliant performers.


The supporting cast, largely carried over from this production’s West End run, is equally impressive. James Phoon and Mara Huf take on the other romantic pairing, Claudio and Hero. Their characterizations fit this production’s world: young and contemporary, but with the blindness and impressionability that drive the second half. Phoon transforms from an earnest young heartthrob into a hurt and angry man grieving the loss of the woman he believes he is going to marry (spoiler alert: he still is). His performance drives much of the play’s darker moments. The production also gives the rest of the company plenty of great material, from Leonato (Forbes Masson) teasing Beatrice about her “merry war” in the first act to Borachio (Mika Onyx Johnson) eavesdropping on Claudio’s plan to woo Hero, setting the tragedy in motion.


Much Ado About Nothing
Much Ado About Nothing

As Margaret, Hero’s waiting woman, Mason Alexander Park dazzles, leading a string of ’90s pop love anthems throughout the show, from Taylor Dayne’s “Tell It to My Heart” at the opening to the aforementioned “When Love Takes Over” at the close. Park is sensational both as a vocalist and in their portrayal of Margaret, particularly when it becomes clear that Margaret has been unwittingly drawn into the scheme. Park is a talent I am glad to see finally cross the pond, and one I hope to see much more onstage in New York in the coming years.


In keeping with his typical style, Lloyd strips Much Ado down to its bare bones. The set, designed by frequent collaborator Soutra Gilmour, consists of a handful of chairs (used to great effect), a small table, and, of course, oodles of pink confetti. An enormous inflatable heart also descends at various points, including one scene in which Hiddleston hides beneath it while listening in on a conversation. Gilmour’s costumes reflect the production’s ’90s club aesthetic. A detail I particularly liked was Atwell’s pantsuit, which reinforces Beatrice’s desire for independence in a world still dominated by men.


The masquerade masks at the ball are another memorable design choice. Where most productions would use those little masks that barely cover the eyes, Gilmour opts for enormous animal heads, completely obscuring the wearer’s face—an essential detail in a plot built around mistaken identities and deception. The masks also reinforce the cat-and-dog dynamic between Beatrice and Benedick. Fabian Aloise’s campy modern choreography, Jon Clark’s striking lighting, and Ben and Max Ringham’s sound design combine to create some truly fantastic club sequences.


Much Ado About Nothing at the Winter Garden Theatre
Much Ado About Nothing at the Winter Garden Theatre

Is this the Shakespeare revival for academics and purists? No, and thank goodness it isn’t. Jamie Lloyd’s Much Ado About Nothing embraces the play’s wacky identity to the fullest, but beneath all the pink confetti, club music, and celebrity winks is a production that understands what makes Shakespeare endure. It isn’t about faithfully recreating Elizabethan London, but about capturing the connection between performers and audience members, all laughing, reacting, and living in the moment together. Perhaps my opening comparison isn’t so insane after all. Lloyd has made a 400-year-old comedy feel less like a relic of the past, read in an English classroom by stone-faced students, and more like one enormous party that you can’t help but want to be a part of. If audiences at the Globe reacted anything like this 400 years ago, I can only regret that I wasn’t a groundling among them.


4.5/5 stars


2 hours and 20 minutes, one intermission

Winter Garden Theatre

Through January 10, 2027


Recent Posts

See All
bottom of page