top of page

Review: In The Heights

Writer: The Verdict
The Verdict
Nov 7
5 min read
In The Heights at New York City Center
In The Heights at New York City Center

Never have I been an audience member at a show more celebratory than when I sat amongst the audience at In The Heights at New York City Center. As the Annual Gala Presentation, this production is playing for only three weeks, but what a feat this was. This first major New York restaging of Lin-Manuel Miranda and Quiara Alegría Hudes’ 2008 blockbuster musical completely reimagines the show, yet still retains the special moments that have endured for so long and make this musical so unique, nodding to the production’s history.


In The Heights is Miranda’s semi-autobiographical story of two couples, a lottery ticket, and the vibrant Latin community in Washington Heights where he grew up. For those familiar with Hamilton, which came after, the musical identity of In The Heights is very similar, only this time, rap and hip-hop beats are merged with the Latin styles heard throughout the neighborhood. Miranda’s trademark lyrical mastery is also on full display. I won’t go into detail since this is a revival, but the plot is a little lacking, with so many characters having different motives and a through-line that is only truly explored in the second act. Hudes’ book does fine handling the many character arcs, but honestly, the story took the backseat for me. I was completely immersed in the fantastic performances, beautiful music, and high-energy staging before me.


In the program, there is a note reminding audiences that this is a concert staging and that actors might be performing with scripts in hand. However, not a single script was used, even by Alora Tonielle Martinez, who made her debut as Graffiti Pete at my performance. Scripts would have inhibited the stunning choreography and full celebration of this musical.


The set of In The Heights, designed by Riw Rakkulchon
The set of In The Heights, designed by Riw Rakkulchon

Director David Mendizábal has completely restaged this production. One of the trademarks of most City Center productions is an onstage orchestra, and to accommodate this, most of the staging takes place in a relatively small space on the main deck. The orchestra is placed on a raised platform, which, along with two towers, invokes the literal George Washington Bridge, a landmark of the Washington Heights neighborhood. However, Riw Rakkulchon’s set also represents the monumental bridge that this musical created between musical theatre, Latin music, and hip-hop, merging the worlds. On the deck below, scenes are shaped by minimal set pieces: signs flying in, the door to Usnavi’s bodega, or a couch for Abuela Claudia. It is simplistic, but highly functional, another staple of City Center.


Under the direction of Alejandro Senior, the orchestra displays its full, lush force. I absolutely loved the richness of the sound, which brought even more life to Miranda’s score and gave the music the full, vibrant energy it deserves.


In front of the bridge structure, there was little room for staging, which was only noticeable during the ensemble numbers, when there seemed to be little variation in how the space was filled. However, what filled the stage was energetic and intricate choreography that I would have expected from a fully staged Broadway revival. Like Miranda’s score, Mayte Natalio’s choreography blended contemporary, hip-hop, and Latin styles, but also added a beautiful moment of balletic dance during Abuela’s number, “Paciencia y Fe,” representing a ghost of Claudia’s past.


The cast of In The Heights
The cast of In The Heights

I also want to take a moment to shout out Justin Townsend’s lighting design. It truly complemented the set, and the strings of lights between the bridge towers drove home that idea of community and family. The blackout sequence was incredibly impressive. One of the drawbacks of an onstage orchestra is that it can never be pitch black—stand lights are necessary—but Townsend works around that by having the actors hold flashlights to illuminate their faces as they sing, making the re-addition of light a natural occurrence, instead of something forced because of technical needs. At the end of that number, he drenches the entire auditorium in beautiful washes of color, imitating fireworks.


The cast is made up of a brilliantly talented group of newcomers to the material. Matte Martinez (MJ The Musical) plays Usnavi, the role originally created by Miranda. Usnavi owns and runs the bodega with his cousin, Sonny (Ishmael Gonzalez, who nearly steals the show through increasingly grating yet nonetheless hilarious comedic bits). Martinez is superb, with fantastic enunciation as he spits out the rapid-fire lyrics. He is charming and grounded enough to lead this show, but still has this boyish nervous energy around Vanessa (Ashley De La Rosa) that keeps him fresh. His quick footwork is impressive too: a physical representation of his eager heart.


We also meet Benny (Aaron James McKenzie), who works at the cab company. He is an outsider in the largely Latin community, and while he fits in well, his boss and the father of his girlfriend, Mr. Rosario (Ivan Hernandez), reminds Benny that he will never truly be a member of the family. Rounding out the central trio is the academic whiz Nina Rosario (the phenomenal Jaci Calderon), “the girl who made it out,” who is celebrated for attending Stanford, only to return home having dropped out after her scholarship was revoked. This sets up the conflict between Nina and her parents: her father prepares to sell the cab company in order to send her back, while her mother (Veronica Vazquez-Jackson) worries about their ability to remain in Washington Heights. Economic difficulty is a constant presence throughout every storyline, setting the backdrop for the increasingly difficult lives New Yorkers in less-affluent neighborhoods face.


We also meet Abuela Claudia, spiritual grandmother to the entire community. Played by Tony Award winner Natalie Venetia Belcon (moonlighting from Buena Vista Social Club), Belcon brings a warmth to the role that establishes her place in the neighborhood. Less a literal “abuela” than the figure whom the entire community reveres, she is the through-line connecting all of the protagonists, but that is not explored in much depth until a tragedy in the second act thrusts her to the center.


The beautiful Moorish design of New York City Center
The beautiful Moorish design of New York City Center

Through this charming cast of characters, the audience is immersed in the culturally rich world of Washington Heights. Led by Linedy Genao (Bad Cinderella) as Daniela, “Carnaval del Barrio” in the second act truly stops the show, as all of the ensemble members dance across the stage sporting flags from across Latin America. It is truly a beautiful moment, even for someone who does not share that heritage, and I found myself moved equally by the audience’s reaction as by what was happening onstage.


Perhaps if this production transfers to Broadway, some revisions to the script—which is not unheard of for City Center productions—could help tackle some of the current issues facing Latin communities, including immigration enforcement. The show retains its celebratory feel while also grounding itself in contemporary issues, making it all the more timely. Ultimately, this In The Heights is a celebration in every sense of the word. While the story may not be its strongest element, the production more than makes up for it with an infectious energy, a remarkably talented cast, and a deep appreciation for the community at its center. This is a musical that has clearly endured for a reason, and City Center’s reimagining reminds audiences just how special it remains.


4.5/5 stars


2 hours and 30 minutes, one intermission

New York City Center

Through November 15, 2026


bottom of page